Book Editing

7 Best Proofreading and Editing Services for Authors

The best proofreading and editing service for your book is the one that does the job your manuscript needs, shows the price before you pay, and proves its work on your own pages. This guide compares seven services for authors on those terms: what each one edits, how it prices, what you see before you pay, and which manuscript it fits. Entry one is Barker Publishing House, the publisher of this blog, so it is described, not ranked.

A manuscript marked in red pen beside a laptop, glasses and coffee, under a banner reading Top Proofreaders.

Proofreading or editing: know what you are buying

Proofreading is the last pass. It catches typos, spacing and formatting errors in a manuscript that is already edited, ideally in the final formatted file. It does not change how the book reads. Scribendi says its book proofreading corrects errors "without changing your content or structure" (Scribendi, Book Proofreading, read November 20, 2026).

If the sentences sag or the chapters drag, you need an edit first. Developmental, line and copy editing compared shows what each pass changes on the page, and book editing services: what you actually get shows what the money buys.

A quick test: if you can describe what is wrong with the manuscript, buy the pass that fixes it. If it is finished and you only need a last check for errors, buy a proofread. If you cannot tell, a sample edit from any service on this list will show you.

How these seven were compared

Each service was read on its own website on November 20, 2026. Prices and terms change, so confirm them on your quote. Five things decide the fit:

  • Scope: which passes it offers, and whether it edits books or mostly papers.
  • Price: a posted rate or an instant quote, before you pay.
  • Proof: a sample on your own pages.
  • Delivery: what comes back, and how fast.
  • Protection: a guarantee or re-edit policy, in writing.

No entry is rated. After entry one, the list runs from book specialists to general and academic services.

1. Barker Publishing House

Not rated: Barker Publishing House is the publisher of this blog, so this entry describes it in its own words. Barker Publishing House edits books in one pass that covers line editing, copyediting and proofreading. The manuscript comes back in 3 business days as a clean Google Doc with every edit applied. In the First Edition's itemized price, book editing is $5,400 at the 90,000 word maximum, and a shorter manuscript costs less. Editing is built into all three editions, which add cover design, formatting and marketing.

Best for: a book whose structure is settled, edited and then designed and published by one team.

Watch: it is an edit and proofread together, not a proofread sold alone. The book editing service and the three editions list what each includes.

2. Reedsy

Reedsy is a marketplace: you choose a freelance editor and work with that person directly. It lists developmental editors, copy editors, proofreaders and editorial assessments, among other services, and you can request quotes from up to five editors at a time after they read your sample pages (Reedsy, Editing, read November 20, 2026). Reedsy says it accepts around 1% of the freelancers who apply to be listed (Reedsy, read November 20, 2026).

Best for: authors who want to pick the person and compare several quotes on the same book.

Watch: each editor sets a price, so the quote, not the platform, decides your cost.

3. Kirkus Editorial

Kirkus posts its prices. Basic Copyediting is 2 cents a word. Collaborative Editing, which covers structure, pacing and tone with line edits and a one-hour call, is $99 plus 3 cents a word. The Professional Editing Package runs a collaborative edit, a copyedit and a final polish for $99 plus 6.5 cents a word. Each has a $500 minimum, and the package has a $500 minimum per stage. Kirkus says every editor must have experience working for a top national publisher, and that about 15 percent of applicants qualify (Kirkus Editorial, read November 20, 2026).

Best for: authors who want posted prices and editors with publishing-house experience.

Watch: proofreading is not sold on its own there; it is the final polish stage of the package.

4. Scribendi

Scribendi has operated since 1997 and sells book editing, book proofreading and book critiques. Its price depends on word count and turnaround, and the instant quote shows both before you commit. Its book editing page lists two weeks for a book of 65,001 to 100,000 words, returns every change as a tracked revision, and offers a free sample edit (Scribendi, Book Editing, read November 20, 2026).

Best for: authors who want a price and a delivery date before they upload the whole book.

Watch: its book proofreading corrects errors only. If the prose needs work, order book editing instead.

5. ProofreadingPal

ProofreadingPal says every document is proofread by two human editors. It offers a free sample on half of your document, up to 400 words, and turnaround from 30 minutes to seven days. It backs the work with a 100% satisfaction guarantee: more work, or a partial or full refund (ProofreadingPal, read November 20, 2026). It has its own page for book proofreading and editing.

Best for: a finished manuscript that needs a final error check with a second reader built in.

Watch: it checks spelling, grammar, punctuation and formatting and suggests improvements. It is not a structural edit.

6. Wordvice

Wordvice edits research papers, theses and dissertations, academic essays, admissions essays and CVs. Its homepage describes its editors as native English speakers with PhDs or master's degrees, and edited files come back in Word with Track Changes on. Premium academic editing includes unlimited free re-edits for 365 days, and Standard editing gives 30% off a re-edit within 21 days (Wordvice, read November 20, 2026). A per-word price calculator shows the cost before you order.

Best for: a paper, a thesis or an admissions essay.

Watch: its pages describe academic and admissions work. A book author should ask whether a book editor is available before ordering.

7. The Editorial Freelancers Association

The EFA is a professional association, not a company that edits. Its member directory filters freelancers by skills and services, genre, editing language, experience, availability, and whether they welcome first-time authors. You can also post your project on its job list. The EFA says a posted job reaches more than 4,000 editorial professionals (Editorial Freelancers Association, read November 20, 2026), and that jobs are typically posted within 48 hours (EFA, Hire a Freelancer, read November 20, 2026).

Best for: authors who want to hire a freelance proofreader or editor directly, at that person's own rate.

Watch: you do the vetting. How to find a book editor covers the checks.

The seven services compared

ServiceWhat it editsHow it pricesBefore you payBest for
Barker Publishing HouseLine editing, copyediting and proofreading in one pass$5,400 at 90,000 words in the First EditionYour exact price on a free strategy callA book edited and published by one team
ReedsyDevelopmental, copy editing, proofreading, assessmentsEach freelancer quotesQuotes from up to five editorsChoosing the person
Kirkus EditorialCopyediting, collaborative editing, a three-stage packagePosted per-word prices, $500 minimumThe posted priceEditors with publishing-house experience
ScribendiBook editing, book proofreading, critiquesWord count and turnaroundInstant quote and a free sample editA fixed price and date up front
ProofreadingPalProofreading with suggestions, two editorsInstant quote by turnaroundFree sample up to 400 wordsA final error check
WordvicePapers, theses, admissions essaysPer-word calculatorThe calculated priceAcademic documents
Editorial Freelancers AssociationWhatever the freelancer you hire offersThe freelancer's own rateDepends on the freelancerHiring directly

What a good proofread sends back

The file you get back tells you how careful the work was. Ask each service what it returns before you order, and expect these four things:

  • Every change visible: tracked changes in the manuscript, or marks on the final pages, so you approve each one.
  • Queries, not guesses: a note wherever the proofreader could not tell what you meant, instead of a silent change.
  • One standard held: spelling, capitals and numbers kept the same way from first page to last, following the style sheet from your copyedit if you have one.
  • A clean final file: a copy with every accepted change applied, ready for formatting or for print.

A proofread that returns a clean file with no record of what changed asks you to trust work you cannot check.

How to choose a proofreading or editing service

  1. Name the job. Write the manuscript's problem in one sentence, then buy the pass that fixes it.
  2. Test on your own pages. Send every service the same passage and compare what comes back.
  3. Get the scope in writing: the pass, the rounds, the file you receive and the return date.
  4. Price the full word count, not a sample rate, and ask what happens if the work runs over.
  5. Check rights and confidentiality. Your manuscript stays private and every right stays yours.

A cheap proofread on a book that needed an edit is money spent twice: you still pay for the edit later. Start with the problem, then pick the service that can show you, on your own pages, how it solves it.

Questions

Questions about proofreading and editing services

Editing improves how the book reads: its structure, its sentences and its consistency. Proofreading is the final check for errors that slipped through. Each pass is shown on the same passage in developmental, line and copy editing compared.
Several services here price proofreading per word, and proofreading usually costs less than an edit because it does less. For proofreading rates beside the other passes, applied to a 90,000 word manuscript, see what a book editor costs.
After. Formatting can add its own errors, such as bad line breaks or wrong running heads, and only a check of the final file catches them. Lock the text, set the pages, then proofread.
A grammar checker catches many spelling and punctuation errors and is worth running first. It cannot judge which changes keep your meaning and your voice. Read what a tool keeps before you paste in a manuscript.
Services that edit academic papers, theses and admissions essays to the rules of journals and style guides, not book publishing. Of the seven here, Wordvice is built for that work.

Ready for pages with nothing left to catch?

Talk to a real publisher first. You leave the call with your exact price for your book.